Toby Brenner, age 94, formerly of Youngstown, Ohio died on December 24, 2025 at Otterbein Sunset House in Ottawa Hills. She was born in Cleveland, Ohio on April 21, 1931 to Anna (Itzkovitz) and Jacob Gutterman. Toby moved to the Toledo area in 2017 to be near her daughter.

Toby was preceded in death by her husband Raymond "Mickey" Brenner in 1998. Surviving is her daughter and son-in-law, Marilyn and Neal Levine of Sylvania, Ohio and two grandchildren.

Services and interment were held on Sunday December  28, 2025 at El Emeth Cemetery in Youngstown, Ohio.